These are Atlanta-area restaurants I’ve tried—so you don’t have to. If they nail it, they make my Good Eats: Atlanta guide. If they don’t, they don’t. Simple.

Stoner’s Pizza Joint

❌ Didn’t make the cut. A late-night lesson in disappointment—and proof that not all cinnamon sticks are created equal.

W. H. Stiles Fish Camp

❌ Didn’t make the cut. Cute location and solid seltzer, but the food lacked finesse. In a city full of standout oyster bars, this one left me with a plate I didn’t want to finish.

Culinary Dropout

✅ Added to the guide. A memorable Atlanta dining experience with delicious food, stylish ambiance, and top-tier service.

Emerald City Bagels

❌ Didn’t make the cut. Emerald City Bagels in Inman Park nails the vibe but misses the mark on flavor—proving not all bagels in Atlanta are created equal.